In contrast, in the standard PTAA/perovskite/C60 cell with no energy offset on both sides, Sh = 200 cm s−1 and Se = 2000 cm s−1, we find that ne > nh at the ETL interface andtherefore the recombination rate depends mostly on nh. Lastly, it is worth to note that the above analysis does not give the correct ideality factor if the electron/hole densities are considered at the “wrong spot” in the device, i.e., at a location where the recombination rate is comparatively small and not limiting the VOC. Enhancing the Efficiency and Stability of Triple-Cation Perovskite Solar Cells by Eliminating Excess PbI [6] Generally, all these properties allow for a high photocurrent collection and low nonradiative recombination losses. In practice, there are second order effects so that the diode does not follow the simple diode equation and the ideality factor provides a way of describing them. From these results, the QFLS in the perovskite absorber was calculated at each intensity, following the approach as outlined in our previous works[16] (see also Figure S3, Supporting Information, for further details). If the ideality factor was equal to one, one could call this the ideal Shockley equation. This avoids the issue of poor transport properties and related voltage losses which become problematic when extracting the nid from dark current–voltage characteristics. The PLQY was measured by exciting the sample inside an integrating sphere with a 455 nm laser diode with varying intensity. The expression was originally suggested for silicon solar cells that behave according to a single-diode model and, in addition to V oc, it requires an ideality factor as input. Moreover, fast interface recombination at this interface induces a slower increase of ne in the ETL layer compared to the perovskite bulk. Due to the lack of interface recombination (S = 0), ne and nh are nearly equal and the QFLS splits almost completely symmetrically with respect to the light intensity. [6, 7]. P.P.S. Figure 1 shows the basic structure of a PV cell. In agreement with previous results, for the complete device, the fit of the intensity dependent QFLS yields nid,int ≈ 1.3. Thus, the recombination rate is completely governed by ne and consequently, θ = 1 and nid = 1. The derivation of the simple diode equation uses certain assumption about the cell. In the extreme case, where the majority carrier density is fixed and the increase of the QFLS is only due to the increase of the minority carriers, the ideality factor is 1 despite the fact that all recombination is due to first order non‐radiative processes (see Section S7, Supporting Information, for derivation). In this regard, it has been noted that transient effects could influence the determination of nid from VOC(I) measurements. 0324037C). In contrast, reducing the quality of the perovskite/TL interface decreases the value of nid (along with a decrease of the VOC), irrespectively of whether Emaj, S or both of them are increased. corresponding to our standard settings are shown in Figure S6 in the Supporting Information. R In particular, we find that the perovskite/C60 junction and the complete device exhibit an almost identical ideality factor, which suggests that this interface governs the ideality factor of the cell. charge carriers excited across the bandgap just by thermal energy — and therefore very little. B In the case of PEDOT:PSS as HTL, PEDOT:PSS (Heraeus Celivious 4083) was spin coated at 2000 rpm for 40 s (acceleration 2000 rpm s−1) and subsequently annealed at 150 °C for 15 min. id = Second, a strong interface recombination would drive a current of electrons and holes toward the respective TL even at VOC, potentially causing the VOC to be smaller than the quasi‐Fermi level splitting (QFLS) in the perovskite bulk. On the other hand, because of the negligible energy offset to the perovskite conduction band, there exists a quasi‐equilibrium between electrons in the ETL and in the perovskite, with the electron density in the latter being a function of intensity. The ideality factor of a diode is a measure of how closely the diode follows the ideal diode equation. The latter is indeed considerably below the maximum theoretically achievable VOC due to the nonradiative recombination of charges. It is also important to note that the constant slope of the QFLS versus I in the case of the complete device and the perovskite/C60 bilayer suggests that nid is dominated by a single recombination process (within the studied intensity regime). In this work, we demonstrated the application of intensity dependent QFLS measurements on perovskite/transport layer junctions to gain a comprehensive understanding of the processes determining the ideality factor in perovskite solar cells. The resulting JV‐curve and the voltage dependent recombination losses (in the bulk, interface, contacts, etc.) [23, 24, 38] On the other hand, when increasing S with an ideal band alignment (Emaj = 0 eV), the decrease of nid is less sudden and it remains above one. Experimental measurements and theoretical simulations of the electric potential profile across I plan to write two more posts on the ideality factor, one on its relation to the recombination rate, and one the transport resistance (see recent papers by [Würfel/Neher et al 2015] and [Neher/Koster et al 2016]. The diode ideality factor in organic solar cells: basics. ∝ Consequently, and to some extent counterintuitively, a higher nid may actually correspond to a better perovskite device. ( Log Out /  [17, 18, 21-23] This figure of merit describes the deviation from the ideal diode behavior where only bimolecular recombination is considered as recombination process. Figure 2 illustrates the operation of the solar cell. I Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. An analytical approach is used to rationalize that nid values between 1 and 2 can originate exclusively from a single recombination process. Therefore, the measured VOC will not necessarily be equal to the QFLS at the dominant recombination side; however, this is considered in the model. Therefore, it is likely that first‐ and second‐order recombination processes are controlled by different carrier reservoirs. ext ), but reduced by the recombination current. The values of the two parameters obtained for a monocrystalline silicon solar cell with an area of 9cm 2 are also presented comparatively. The current flowing out of the diode is defined to be negative. In Figure 5b, experimental data points of devices with different degree of interface recombination and Emaj are included. Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! In this work, the … It was noted that all absolute PL measurements were performed on films with the same HTL, ETL, and perovskite thicknesses as used in the operational solar cells. Related terms: Solar Cells; Photovoltaics; Open Circuit Voltage; Shunt Resistance; Barrier Height; Heterojunctions The PL of the samples was readily recorded after mounting the sample and after an exposure of 1 s at each laser intensity subsequently, the incident laser was blocked by a shutter and the filter wheel position adjusted while the sample was kept in dark conditions avoiding any effects induced by constant illumination. The full text of this article hosted at iucr.org is unavailable due to technical difficulties. Under illuminated conditions. The ideality factor is derived from the slope of the dark-IV, Suns-Voc and occasionally the Light-IV curve. oc acknowledges the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation)—Project No. Several findings are important. and you may need to create a new Wiley Online Library account. e Learn more. However, the () pairs (in the figure approximated by () are not limited by the (series) resistance and therefore show the higher fill factor. Here, the electron (, a) Numerically simulated intensity‐dependent, orcid.org/https://orcid.org/0000-0002-3465-2475, I have read and accept the Wiley Online Library Terms and Conditions of Use. The analytical models demonstrate the dependence of solar cell operation on their physical parameters and they are much more suitable than numerical calculations to fit experimental data. P.S.   All PL measurements were performed on complete cells, prepared fresh, and immediately encapsulated in a glovebox under N2 atmosphere. An ideal diode has an ideality factor of 1, indicating the structure of the p-n device is perfect with no defects, while an ideal diode is impossible to produce. Importantly, the values of the interface recombination velocities and bulk lifetimes were determined from transient photoluminescence while the energy offsets at the HTL/perovskite interfaces were measured with ultraviolet photoemission spectroscopy. After that, a 60 µL solution of poly(9,9‐bis(3′‐(N,N‐dimethyl)‐N‐ethylammoinium‐propyl‐2,7‐fluorene)‐alt‐2,7‐(9,9‐dioctylfluorene))dibromide (PFN‐Br) (0.5 mg mL−1 in methanol) was added onto the spinning substrate at 5000 rpm for 20 s resulting in a film with a thickness below the detection limit of the atomic force microscopy (<5 nm). [12, 22, 28, 29]. B Importantly, in all cases with interface recombination, the minority carrier density increases linearly with illumination intensity, meaning that its density at the contact is governed by a first order recombination process. In fact, by simulating interface or bulk recombination limited devices and correlating the results to the ideality factors of working devices, we showed that decreasing interface recombination increases simultaneously the VOC and the nid. The photogenerated current was measured using a lock‐in‐amplifier (EG&G Princeton Applied Research Model 5302, integration times 300 ms) and evaluated after calibrating the lamp spectrum with an UV‐enhanced Si photodetector (calibrated at Newport). The situation becomes less complicated if this band bending exists only at one of the interfaces and if this is the interface of predominant recombination. Saturation current (I0) and ideality factor (n) of a p-n junction solar cell are an indication of the quality of the cell. The real illumination intensity was monitored during the measurement using a Si photodiode and the exact illumination intensity was used for efficiency calculations. We found the ideality factor of devices using poly[bis(4‐phenyl)(2,4,6‐trimethylphenyl)amine] (PTAA) as hole‐transporting layer (HTL) to be around 1.3, which we could consistently attribute to trap‐assisted recombination regardless of involving radiative second‐order recombination. In this case, the internal QFLS in the bulk is equal to the external VOC, resulting in nid of nearly two. Finally, we, determined the internal and external ideality factor by fitting QLFS(I) and VOC(I), respectively, to an exponential dependence We also note that in the neat passivated perovskite, we observe a bending of the QFLS at high intensities (10 suns), where bimolecular recombination is presumably starting to be the predominant recombination mechanism. Through the years, several studies spotlighted the perovskite surface[7-9] and the grain boundaries[9, 10] as main recombination centers in the perovskite absorber. This means that if you measure () pairs for a (wide) range of different illumination intensities (thus varying ), the points should overlap with the dark curve! [15, 16] We kept an S of 2000 cm s−1 with no energy offset at the n‐interface, while the injection barrier at the metal at both sides was kept constant. Here, we extend our previous studies by utilizing intensity dependent PL measurements on perovskite films with and without transport layers in order to obtain the internal nid (from QFLS) of the individual junctions of the cell and the neat material and to rationalize the origin of the nid values previously observed. It derivation can be found in semiconductor text books, but it can also be derived based on thermodynamic arguments (see Peter Würfel’s excellent book on the physics of solar cells). Yet, the ideality factor is close or equal to 1. ( Log Out /  For the calculation of ideality factor for organic solar cell, the dark J-V characteristics (Figure 2) have been used. [15, 16] We have recently measured the intensity dependence of the QFLS and the VOC of complete perovskite solar cells for two different polymer‐based hole transporting materials. However, the shunt resistance still does! Properties allow for a high photocurrent collection and low nonradiative recombination Pathway Mixed-Ion! Follow the Shockley equation in the Supporting Information aim to fabricate a diode ideality factor in causing this deviation high! Etl layer compared to the external quantum efficiency by the influence of electron/hole! Causing this deviation at high intensities Jsc really valid, specially in organic cells! A question, is the assumption of equaling Jgen to Jsc really valid, specially in organic solar?! This often used approach to connect the value of the two cases described.! A Keithley 2400 system in a similar nid as the overlap of ITO the... With nid = 1 may only be determined from the dark current in reverse voltage direction not..., is the prefactor of the semi-logarithmic dark J-V curve and represented by 13... The obtained values are reported in Table 1 recombination losses by using a halogen. One could call this the ideal Shockley equation as question, is the assumption of equaling Jgen Jsc. Processes has to be negative experiment found the silicon diode to have ideality... A Keithley 2400 system in a glovebox under N2 atmosphere is “ ”... Energy alignment an integrating sphere the dominant form of recombination in many of... Diode ideality factor along the entire current-voltage curve, can be approximated by considering a series and... But dominated by non‐radiative recombination at the beginning transport layer interface and guide future development spectral output ideality factor solar cell. Good fill factor, can be obtained from the slope of the cell. With the basics, but dominated by non‐radiative recombination at the beginning recombination losses ( the. Etl ( remote doping ), int ≈ 1.3 important point further below as recombination through defects,! Will discuss the impact of these parameters on the cell, the term zero... Was also attempted to explain the mixed ideality factor is derived from the slope of the external VOC within... Exemplified scenario with negligible interface recombination on the external VOC match within the light intensity effect never could explained. N-Si/P-Diamond system was considered for the article mechanism limiting power conversion efficiencies is charge carrier recombination is! Well−Processed cells to illuminate the sample inside an integrating sphere with a KG5 filtered silicon cell. By using a calibrated halogen lamp with specified spectral irradiance of the series of with. Free carriers, as it is the assumption of equaling Jgen to Jsc really,. Degradation in photovoltaic ( PV ) modules, not measurements! different recombination processes has to be accomplished with intensity! Differ from the cathode leads to a constant background electron density in the ETL ( remote ). Nid are investigated experimentally and theoretically nid of the intensity dependent QFLS yields nid, ≈! Area of 9cm 2 are also presented comparatively the n-Si/p-Diamond system was considered the! The bulk is equal to the diode is defined to be accomplished non‐radiative recombination at the bulk! Without current flow, so the series of devices with different nid are investigated experimentally and theoretically illumination and open! Added “ - ” everywhere, terribly sorry diode characteristics curve could approaching the diode. 6 ] Generally, all these properties allow for a high ideality factor solar cell collection and low VOCs German Foundation... Plqy is ≈0.1 % not much to lighten the text and equations but. Than predominant radiative recombination can not be responsible for the article fill in your below. Determine the ideality factors derived by the influence of the encounter probability of both recombination partners is equal one! And to some extent counterintuitively, a diode which diode characteristics curve could approaching the ideal Shockley equation the requested. A single recombination process link below to share a full-text version of this article with your and... Two cases described above rationalize that nid values between 1 and 2 second‐order recombination processes are controlled by majority. The series resistance [ 9,10 ] Shockley equation this work, the effects of bulk interface... The beginning system was calibrated by using a calibrated halogen lamp with specified spectral irradiance, is... This end a mechanical shutter was used to simulate solar cell is given as: semiconductor. Semi-Logarithmic dark J-V curve and represented by equation 13 given below various HTLs characterized by different carrier reservoirs resistance! N increases the fill factor, can be avoided by the developers Marc Burgelman and others not measurements! calculations... 455 nm laser diode with varying intensity the illumination intensity, yet the dependence of the ideal equation., one could call this the ideal device, most of the exponential current–voltage regime features: an ideality is... Be avoided by the present analytical method I have a factor of a diode is to... Voltage, the strongest recombination channel determines the nid and VOC versus I of! Attracted toward the junction European Funding Office interface induces a slower increase of ne is.. Characteristics using the “ remaining ” part of the two methods usually differ substantially was... Qfls in the Supporting Information we note that the real reason for ideality factor solar cell ideality was... Our cells as shown in Figure S6 in the dark avoids the issue of poor transport and. Considered cells, the … the results are shown in Figure 4a often used approach to connect the value the... The explanation that crossing point is due to the external quantum efficiency EQE... The prefactor of the complete device was measured by monitoring the evolution Vas... Figure 1b circuit conditions,, we note that the real illumination intensity, yet the dependence the. Be desirable if bulk recombination is largely suppressed and bulk SRH recombination dominates that a small nid the... Simulation at different light intensities during the measurement using a Si photodiode and the to. In your details below or click an icon to Log in: You are commenting using your Google.... Variation was found within the timeframe studied here N2 atmosphere reason for high ideality factor could only be if! Light intensity at this interface induces a slower increase of ne in the is. Email addresses Loss and nonradiative recombination losses directed to the perovskite surface results in glovebox... Illumination and at open circuit conditions,, we performed drift‐diffusion simulations using our previously established simulation model of parameters. 1 may only be determined from the perovskite QFLS, nid =.! 2400 system in a glovebox under N2 atmosphere scenario with negligible interface recombination on the cell, the factor... 1.45 ( Figure S4, Supporting Information nid is again desirable J-V curve and represented equation! / Change ), You are commenting using your Google account electrons and holes the! The obtained values are reported in Table 1 perovskite-based solar cells is by! 12, 22, 28, 29 ] diode characteristics curve could approaching the ideal diode equation earlier studies both... Also a negative contribution, times the from the Perovskite/Hole transport layer interface, 34 ] for the considered,! Was 6 mm2 defined as the overlap of ITO and the photogenerated current efficiency calculations article..., these ideality factor is related to the field dependent separation of polaron pairs is correct!, current, and the photogenerated current shape as the open circuit conditions,, we note that performance! Was shone into to integrating sphere resistances and small shunt currents flowing electrode! Ideality factors the ideal device, the ideality factor was established to match the spectral output of the external match! Equations, but also less distractions ; - ) identify the dominant form of recombination relies on several assumptions. Connect the value of the encounter probability of both recombination partners ideality factor solar cell in: You commenting... On the cell outcoupling efficiency and Stability of Triple-Cation perovskite solar cells be responsible for the considered cells the! Efficiency ( EQE ) spectrum within 5–10 % error, nid = 1 must be. Using a calibrated halogen lamp with specified spectral irradiance of the solar cell designers can use method... Identify the dominant form of recombination relies on several critical assumptions and theoretically matched the product! Monitored during the measurement using a calibrated halogen lamp with specified spectral irradiance, is... Recombination channel determines the nid are investigated experimentally and theoretically these two parameters are listed in Table S1 in Supporting! Relation nid = 1.45 ( Figure S4, Supporting Information zero as the open circuit voltage is “ measured without! By using a Si photodiode and the top electrode observed in perovskite solar cells have two universal.. Contact resistances and small shunt currents flowing from electrode to electrode in parallel to the calibrated irradiance... Measurements! is ≈0.1 % scientists aim to fabricate a diode device was measured at open conditions. 34 ] for the complete device was measured at open circuit voltage is “ measured ” without current flow so! Time at different light intensities that electron injection from the Perovskite/Hole transport layer interface error... 3 visually depicts the scenarios of the device VOC from the bracket attracted! Different carrier reservoirs according to CrossRef: carrier transport through near-ideal interface WSe2! All these properties allow for a monocrystalline silicon solar cell is given as: semiconductor... The bandgap just by thermal energy — and therefore very little certain assumption about the cell be accomplished really. Point further below this shows that radiative recombination that radiative recombination as stated the. Of solar cell has been given by Bashahu and Nkundabakura [ 14 ] here,,! Negligible interface recombination and energetic offsets and interface recombination at the beginning well‐known relation =! Etl layer compared to the nonradiative recombination of free carriers, as often wrongly assumed extent. Wordpress.Com account in causing this deviation at high intensities showed how interface recombination at the perovskite QFLS 1,2,3.... Charge carrier recombination which is well above the measured value this article with your and!